"A Witch's Guide to Magical Murder" Review by Farahilda (4.25/5 stars) I stumbled upon this book during one of my late-night bookstore wanderings (yes, I'm that witch who haunts bookshops after midnight), and the premise of a PI witch returning to her magical hometown instantly caught my attention. As someone who also left their magical community under... complicated circumstances, I felt an immediate connection to Beatrix's story. Let me tell you, this book was like a perfectly brewed potion - mostly delightful with just a few bitter notes that didn't quite sit right. The magical small-town setting of Witchlight Cove absolutely enchanted me, especially the fayre with its pie-eating contest (though I do wish they'd included more details about the magical baking techniques - I have opinions about levitating pastries!). The mystery element kept me turning pages well into the witching hour, with enough red herrings to stock a magical fishmonger. I particularly enjoyed how the author wove themes of homecoming and facing one's past throughout the narrative. Beatrix's relationship with her dog Eva warmed my heart - as someone who shares my cottage with three familiars (two cats and a rather opinionated raven), I completely understand that bond. However, I found myself occasionally frustrated with Beatrix's character development. For a supposedly experienced PI, she sometimes made decisions that had me wanting to throw protective wards around her. There were moments when her professional expertise seemed to vanish faster than a poorly cast illusion, especially when dealing with people from her past. The romantic subplot felt a bit rushed, like a love potion that hadn't simmered long enough. I would have appreciated more time developing that connection naturally, though I understand some readers enjoy a faster-paced romance. Despite these minor grievances, I found myself thoroughly invested in the story, especially as it raced toward its shocking conclusion. The world-building is delightful, and the supporting characters (particularly Maddie and Yanni) add wonderful depth to the narrative. Would I recommend this book? Absolutely, especially to those who enjoy their mysteries with a magical twist. It's perfect for reading on a rainy evening with a cup of enchanted tea (my personal recipe includes moonflower petals and starlight). Just don't expect a cozy mystery - this one has more bite than your average magical tale. Now, if you'll excuse me, I need to go pre-order the sequel before my familiar uses my bookmark as a chew toy again.